The One That Got Away!
Getting started

I've noticed that you never see watercolour demonstrations that went wrong - so....I'm going to occasionally post a step-by-step watercolour demo that got away on me. Just for the fun of it. I usually destroy such disasters, or paint on the other side of the paper, but I invariably learn something from the experience. These mishaps are long gone, but I kept the files for future use. I'm starting with my attempt to paint some lilies. These photographs were taken in the days before digital cameras.

Great reference photo

I was inspired to paint these beautiful lilies many years ago, and I started out with such high hopes. I saw this as a colour-drenched painting with the light shining through the petals. I saw dramatic shadows enhancing the rich orange hues, and so on, and  so on. Alas, my reach exceeded my grasp.

So far, so good

I started off full of confidence with a careful drawing projected onto my 300lb Arches watercolour paper. I spent some considerable time deciding exactly how I was going to paint this picture, and started off by putting in a basic blue background to set off the rich, vibrant hue of the lilies - I hoped.

Bad colour choice

Now it starts to go wrong. If I remember I used an orange composed of New Gamboge and Cadmium Red, two hopelessly opaque colours guaranteed to ruin just the effect I wanted to achieve. I laid on my first wash happily oblivious to the damage I was doing..

Something's not quite right

With some strategic misket work I began making the petals three-dimentional, although I remember thinking at the time something was wrong here; my petals didn't shimmer and shine. No matter - press on and hope for the best.

Close-up

I was so pleased with myself I even took a close-up for posterity

Nagging doubts

Now for the greens to enhance the rich orange hue of these glowing petals. I'm still quite confident, but in my heart of hearts I know something is terribly wrong but I put it down to early fears. If I remember, I put this aside for a fews days before coming back to it, and this nagging feeling that something was wrong would not go away.

It's getting muddy now

Oh dear, oh dear - what is happening to my lovely lilies? My painting is getting muddier and muddier. I try pouring on the orange hue in the shadows to breathe some life into this thing. By now I'm slightly sick to my stomach with fear.

Put it aside once more

I desperately try to boost the green stalks to give me some bounce, but I know this has got away from me. I think I put this aside again for a few days to calm my nerves.

Time to give up

Back to the scene of the crime and I hopelessly overwork the greenery and realize my muddy painting cannot be salvaged. The sequential photographs cease at this point, although I remember I struggled to get the greenery to balance the petals, and I probably over-painted the petals in desperation. I eventually gave up. Looking at this disaster after a few years the photographs don't look as bad as I remember, but we're viewing them as a kind of slide-show using  transmitted light, not reflective light as a painting is normally viewed. I never had the courage to try this again, and the moral of this story is   - what the hell - you can't win 'em all!